Bachelorette 16 - Clare Crawley & Tayshia Adams - Media SM - *Sleuthing Spoilers* #2

The spoiler may well be right and Zac is Tayshia’s F1, but I’ll admit I’m skeptical about RS’s track record about spoiling the B’ette F1. He has come out initially with an incorrect spoiler so many times. He does usually correct it by the end though. Since I haven’t watched too much in recent years I wondered when was the last time RS spoiled the F1 of the B’ette correctly out of the gate and didn’t have to revise his spoiler.

Looking at his recent history with initial spoilers this is what I found. (Please let me know if I got any of this wrong as I haven’t watched Becca - Kaitlyn.):

Clare - Life&Style spoiled the season. RS didn’t know anything initially.
Hannah B - RS incorrectly spoiled Tyler and later changed it
Becca - TMZ spoiled the season. Is that right?
Rachel - RS incorrectly spoiled Peter. Did he later correct it?
JoJo - RS correctly spoiled Jordan. Is that right?
Kaitlyn - ? All I know is Kaitlyn spoiled the season herself.
Andi - I can’t remember if RS spoiled Josh. I did watch a tiny bit of it.
Des - RS incorrectly spoiled Brooks. Oof. I was so bummed it wasn’t Brooks I mostly stopped watching the show.

If my info here is right this means the last time RS spoiled a B’ette  season correctly out of the gate it was JoJo? Is that correct?

gabriele wrote:The spoiler may well be right and Zac is Tayshia’s F1, but I’ll admit I’m skeptical about RS’s track record about spoiling the B’ette F1. He has come out initially with an incorrect spoiler so many times. He does usually correct it by the end though. Since I haven’t watched too much in recent years I wondered when was the last time RS spoiled the F1 of the B’ette correctly out of the gate and didn’t have to revise his spoiler.

Looking at his recent history with initial spoilers this is what I found. (Please let me know if I got any of this wrong as I haven’t watched Becca - Kaitlyn.):

Clare - Life&Style spoiled the season. RS didn’t know anything initially.
Hannah B - RS incorrectly spoiled Tyler and later changed it
Becca - TMZ spoiled the season. Is that right?
Rachel - RS incorrectly spoiled Peter. Did he later correct it?
JoJo - RS correctly spoiled Jordan. Is that right?
Kaitlyn - ? All I know is Kaitlyn spoiled the season herself.
Andi - I can’t remember if RS spoiled Josh. I did watch a tiny bit of it.
Des - RS incorrectly spoiled Brooks. Oof. I was so bummed it wasn’t Brooks I mostly stopped watching the show.

If my info here is right this means the last time RS spoiled a B’ette  season correctly out of the gate it was JoJo? Is that correct?

Rachel: RS later corrected himself and said she picked Bryan
Andi: one of RS friends was on the same flight with Nick and recorded his phone conversation with his dad that basically spoiled himself as F2. RS was vey lucky that season!

But no matter what RS says, this board always sleuths! I believe Zac is F1, not because RS said so, but because the excellent sleuthing work this board has done!

Thanks @sdmom! How could I forget about Nick’s plane video. Wasn’t he eating a bag of chips too?

So, JoJo was the last time RS spoiled a season correctly out of the gate. And, if we want to look for patterns he is due to spoil it incorrectly this time.

RS said Kaitlyn didn't pick anyone.

RS said Kaitlyn was single and never said it was Shawn until she spoiled it and made up some excuse. I don't remember what he said as it was 5 years ago

I never believe his 'ette F1 picks as we can see he's been wrong the past few years minus JoJo. Not sure yet who it could be maybe Zac also think Tayshia could be engaged as I doubt she wanted to leave single/not engaged.

BlackHalo wrote:RS said Kaitlyn didn't pick anyone.

That made me and say "no way in hell would she be single." and I remember seeing posts that some thought Kaitlyn was dating them both and then going to decide at the AFTR.

@sdmom


When in doubt, single is a good choice.

Ali was single too. Sleuthers @MiniDiva found transfer paper's with Allstate for Roberto, to California from the Carolina's. Also, there was a poster who supposedly worked at the resort that claimed Roberto was the F1. But when people jump on a forum, and post info like that, it's hard to believe them, until sluethers noticed  Roberto changed his twitter profile with a straw hat at the FRC location.

Sleuthing most often wins!

Thanks everyone for the correct info!  

So, the Reddit insider, thesensitivechild, seems to be saying today that Tayshia and Zac are either broken up and will basically be together for appearances at ATFR or Tayshia is single. I’m still not sure what to think yet, but I’m definitely not taking RS on faith.

Reddit read what I and quietgirl posted about Brendan yesterday on the F4 thread, was totally scoffing at it, and today lots of them are now wondering about Brendan. I don’t have a strong feeling yet on who is F1 but am just wondering aloud. No whiplash necessary.

Okay, the Christmas tree ornament hanging from the forum is too cute!

When it comes to the Bachelorette , RS also got Becca's season completely correct.

kmick0890 wrote:When it comes to the Bachelorette , RS also got Becca's season completely correct.

That’s not true

TMZ got the FRC pictures first on May 24. 2018 https://www.tmz.com/2018/05/24/bachelorette-finale-becca-kufrin-kissing-fiance-spoiler-pics/
Even RS himself acknowledged “ TMZ posted pictures from Becca’s final rose ceremony in the Maldives this morning which clearly shows Becca is engaged to Garrett. ‘ https://realitysteve.com/2018/05/24/the-bachelorette-becca-spoilers-finale-spoiler/

So the point is: RS’ track record of B’ette is pretty bad

sdmom wrote:

kmick0890 wrote:When it comes to the Bachelorette , RS also got Becca's season completely correct.

That’s not true

TMZ got the FRC pictures first on May 24. 2018 https://www.tmz.com/2018/05/24/bachelorette-finale-becca-kufrin-kissing-fiance-spoiler-pics/
Even RS himself acknowledged “ TMZ posted pictures from Becca’s final rose ceremony in the Maldives this morning which clearly shows Becca is engaged to Garrett. ‘ https://realitysteve.com/2018/05/24/the-bachelorette-becca-spoilers-finale-spoiler/

So the point is: RS’ track record of B’ette is pretty bad

I forgot about that.

gabriele wrote:>snip<
JoJo - RS correctly spoiled Jordan. Is that right?
>snip<
If my info here is right this means the last time RS spoiled a B’ette  season correctly out of the gate it was JoJo? Is that correct?

I don’t remember that, but it seems likely.
IIRC though, before the finale he claimed that they were already broken up, so he doesn’t get full credit for that one either.
Since more people trusted him blindly back then, it got quite ugly on SM when they were accused of faking it at ATFR and afterwards.
JMO