Bachelor 24 - Peter Weber - F1-F4 - Discussion - *Sleuthing Spoilers*

Discuss final 4 here.

sdmom wrote:Maybe we can have a f4 Discussion thread? @guardianangel

bluwavz wrote:

(SPOILER): The hometown date filming order is as follows:

Sat 10/26 - Madison Prewett, Auburn, AL
Mon 10/28 - Victoria Fuller, Virginia Beach, VA
Wed 10/30 - Hannah Sluss, Knoxville, TN
Fri 11/1 - Kelsey Weier, Des Moines, IA

If you’re in VA, you can attend Monday’s date pic.twitter.com/ZafI4ZmOu7

— RealitySteve (@RealitySteve) October 25, 2019

And yes, I’m aware that Hannah Brown is in Auburn, AL this wknd as well for a friends wedding. I’d say it’s just a coincidence Peter’s first hometown is tmrw in Auburn, but I don’t put anything past this show anymore. Esp since Hannah has already shown up twice on his season.

— RealitySteve (@RealitySteve) October 25, 2019

I am going to predict
F1 - Madi
F2 - Hannah
F3 - Kelsy
F4 - Victoria

What I'm hoping for
F1 - Kelsey
F2 - Victoria F. (Bachelorette)
F3 - Madison
F4 - Hannah

What I'm expecting
F1 - Madison
F2 - Hannah (Bachelorette)
F3 - Kelsey
F4 - Victoria F.

Still holding out some hope that they'll pick Tammy for Bachelorette, but I don't know if she made it far enough.

I’m going to guess:

F1 - Madison
F2 - Victoria
F3 - Hannah (Bachelorette)
F4 - Kelsey

Kind of changed my mind this morning and switched my f1/f2 but right now I am thinking.

F1- Hannah Ann
F2 - Madison
F3 - Victoria F
F4 - Kelsey

F1 - Hannah
F2 - Kelsey
F3 - Victoria F.
F4 - Madison

I can't shake the feeling that either Hannah or Madison will be a ~shock elimination~ at F4. They seem very similar IMO (it'd basically be sweet southern 23 year old brunette vs sweet southern 23 year old brunette with 30k more followers ) so I think production would want the F2 to be more of a contrast.

smg2587 wrote:Kind of changed my mind this morning and switched my f1/f2 but right now I am thinking.

F1- Hannah Ann
F2 - Madison
F3 - Victoria F
F4 - Kelsey

Has a FIR recipient ever became f1 in Bach history? Not counting B’ette.

sdmom wrote:

smg2587 wrote:Kind of changed my mind this morning and switched my f1/f2 but right now I am thinking.

F1- Hannah Ann
F2 - Madison
F3 - Victoria F
F4 - Kelsey

Has a FIR recipient ever became f1 in Bach history? Not counting B’ette.

Nope. But no one who had their first 1-on-1 in episode 4 has been F1 in the Bachelor, which is the episode Kelsey and Victoria F had theirs. And I'm 99% sure Madison got the first 1-on-1, and Becca is the only F1 in history who had the first 1-on-1. And Becca barely counts as an F1  So no matter who the F1 is, it's going to be something different. I think Victoria P eliminating herself has forced Peter to have a change of plans but that's JMO.

Hawaii Girl wrote:

sdmom wrote:

smg2587 wrote:Kind of changed my mind this morning and switched my f1/f2 but right now I am thinking.

F1- Hannah Ann
F2 - Madison
F3 - Victoria F
F4 - Kelsey

Has a FIR recipient ever became f1 in Bach history? Not counting B’ette.

Nope. But no one who had their first 1-on-1 in episode 4 has been F1 in the Bachelor, which is the episode Kelsey and Victoria F had theirs. And I'm 99% sure Madison got the first 1-on-1, and Becca is the only F1 in history who had the first 1-on-1. And Becca barely counts as an F1  So no matter who the F1 is, it's going to be something different. I think Victoria P eliminating herself has forced Peter to have a change of plans but that's JMO.

So based on the past patterns, Peter picks no one!

All kidding aside, Peter has surprised me with some of his choices. I can’t wait to see where Kelsey is placed, since, IMO, she is very different from the other three,

Hawaii Girl wrote:

sdmom wrote:

smg2587 wrote:Kind of changed my mind this morning and switched my f1/f2 but right now I am thinking.

F1- Hannah Ann
F2 - Madison
F3 - Victoria F
F4 - Kelsey

Has a FIR recipient ever became f1 in Bach history? Not counting B’ette.

Nope. But no one who had their first 1-on-1 in episode 4 has been F1 in the Bachelor, which is the episode Kelsey and Victoria F had theirs. And I'm 99% sure Madison got the first 1-on-1, and Becca is the only F1 in history who had the first 1-on-1. And Becca barely counts as an F1  So no matter who the F1 is, it's going to be something different. I think Victoria P eliminating herself has forced Peter to have a change of plans but that's JMO.

Don't they usually keep the F1 hidden until 5th week at least and then they go on a one on one date? I don't know if producers follow the same pattern that they followed years ago but i was told (and also mentioned it on this forum years ago) that the lead gets to choose their top 4 girls after night 1 that they are most interested in getting to know better and the producers form the dates around that and then producers choose the rest of the girls that they want to stay on to create the show , the drama and the eliminations. just saying., (And they watch to see who the viewers like the best and who gets the most followers to cast for next show),Now if Victoria P was high on his list of those initial 4 and she left then I think the bachelor would have a say in who he wants to fill that spot to bring along to Final 4. Will be interesting to see it all play out. I like Peter and I hope he finds he's forever partner ., I just hope Victoria P wasen't the one he was focused on from night 1 and we don't get a repeat of Deanna who really wanted Graham and was devastated when he left at F4 and she rebounded with Jesse. all jmo but that's the way I saw her season.

@Jolena It varies. Typically on the Bachelor, the F1 has had their first 1-on-1 in week 3. The Bachelorette is where it's usually week 5. The producers do pick who gets what date based on who the lead likes though. Colton has talked about having to list the women in preferential order every week.

Hawaii Girl wrote:@Jolena It varies. Typically on the Bachelor, the F1 has had their first 1-on-1 in week 3. The Bachelorette is where it's usually week 5. The producers do pick who gets what date based on who the lead likes though. Colton has talked about having to list the women in preferential order every week.

If I remember correctly, Cassie's one on one was week 5. Andrew Firestone with Jen was week 5, I think Arie with Lauren was week 5, and im sure there were more that were put off until week 5. I don't recall any F.1's getting dates as early as week 3 Do you recall any?