DWTS - Season 28 - Episodes - Discussion - *Sleuthing Spoilers*

Billysmom wrote:Demi looked pretty sad in the audience....

Well Demi and the rest of her friends know Hannah is working her butt off. Even Peta M said in the article posted upthread that no one is working as hard as Hannah but it is what it is at this point, she can only take the feedback and try to continue to improve, that’s life.

are you kidding me, Alaina got 3 9's!!!

alwayscooking wrote:are you kidding me, Alaina got 3 9's!!!

Yep....and according to Carrie Anne, she performed it well but her steps were not clean to me. And wait for it...she has Bobby Jones campaigning hard for her as well and she might win it all at this point. I have Lauren Alaina and James locked for the finale just based on what I am seeing from the judges.

Based on the scores others got I disagree with Hannah’s scores. However I agree with the comments she needs to take off her pageant mask and be the real her. She doesn’t have much personality in her dance. Janes would have (should have) been all 10s had he not slipped. Others are definitely catching up to Hannah talent wusrr. All iMO.

Now I know why I don't watch this show any longer, I hate that the judges are such d!@cks. If they want a true competition then cast everyone that has the same dance/athletic ability.. But when you have someone that's 25 and has had dance experience to someone that's 60 and has had no dance experience and then rip them up one side and down another that they're not up to par with the others, what the heck do they expect???

I agree with Len on Pasha and I love his choreo but if Kate gets all 9’s, then I have no idea what these judges are on!!!

Even the team trick’s dance song selection sucks, these producers that took over this season need to go IMO.

Carrie Ann is a joker, wonder if someone in production whispered to her to apologize to Hannah who was now choking tears back. I just wish Carrie Ann would go as hard on the other contestants as well, can’t be a challenge to be fair when it comes to constructive criticism IMO.

IMO what’s costing Hannah is Alan’s choreography. Her dance tonight was lackluster because the routine was sort of boring. She performs what is given to her well but, he’s not giving her exciting dances, and it’s very unfortunate because she could and would do better with better routines, IMO. I wish she had been paired with Val or Zeb or, the new guy Pasha who is excellent. All IMO.

Chgohighlife wrote:IMO what’s costing Hannah is Alan’s choreography. Her dance tonight was lackluster because the routine was sort of boring. She performs what is given to her well but, he’s not giving her exciting dances, and it’s very unfortunate because she could and would do better with better routines, IMO. I wish she had been paired with Val or Zeb or, the new guy Pasha who is excellent. All IMO.

Couldn't agree with you more and I mentioned last week that I wasn't a fan of Alan's choreography. Plus, I think they've given her pretty sucky music. Add CA's crankiness/lack of tact when giving feedback and I can completely understand why Hannah would be in tears.

I have no words watching Team Treat other than IA that the wall was a good idea to hide some major missteps

Chgohighlife wrote:IMO what’s costing Hannah is Alan’s choreography. Her dance tonight was lackluster because the routine was sort of boring. She performs what is given to her well but, he’s not giving her exciting dances, and it’s very unfortunate because she could and would do better with better routines, IMO. I wish she had been paired with Val or Zeb or, the new guy Pasha who is excellent. All IMO.

I haven’t watched tonight’s epi yet, but agree with these comments around Alan’s choreography from watching past weeks’ dances. As the competition progresses it’ll become more apparent, especially in a freestyle, should she get that far.

What do we think of how alan handled the question they asked him?

Btw momma C is still team Hannah and not happy with her scores either, ...