Bachelor 24 - Peter Weber - General Discussion - *Sleuthing Spoilers*

Scenario 2 - Dating Hannah Ann

Madi left and Peter is befumbled and isn’t sure what to do. He tells HA Madi was going to be F1 and that he isn’t sure what to do now and can’t decide right then. He decides to chase Madi down but she turns him down because he slept with other women and she’s not comfortable with that. He contacts HA for a second chance and HA agrees to date but not get engaged thus exhibiting “backbone” that CH said she has in that meet the women video. HA is feeling a little salty toward Madi as Madi could have left earlier and not ruined her happy ending.

Questions & Doubts

Would Madi really leave and not take him back? Would Peter really try again with HA?

Scenario 3 - Dating Both Women

Peter couldn’t decide what to do after Madi left so he doesn’t break things off completely with HA but also tries to see if Madi will come back to him. Madi doesn’t want to get engaged and Peter hedges his bets and dates both.

Questions & Doubts

Not sure this is too likely.

Scenario 4 - Peter is single

Madi leaves and Peter sends HA home so he can go chase down Madi. Madi turns him down and now he’s single. He may or may not contact HA but if he does she turns him down too.

Questions & Doubts

No idea if this is possibly true.

——————

So, what do you think? Any of these scenarios or do you have another one?

Only way to figure that out is through the caps.  Who has each FD?  What are they doing?  We only know 100% for VF.  We only know 100% for the day portion for HS.  We don't have anything for Madi verifying one way or another.  If Madi is going to an amusement park and then ends up having no night FD, then I think HS is F1.

Remember, RS keeps saying that if he said who is F1, then why did Peter's mom say 'Don't let her go' and why did Chris say, before you do this that upsets Peter.  That tells me he hears HS is F1 and has nothing to back it up.

eta

It would also be helpful to know which of the F3 handlers were.

atem wrote:Only way to figure that out is through the caps.  Who has each FD?  What are they doing?  We only know 100% for VF.  We only know 100% for the day portion for HS.  We don't have anything for Madi verifying one way or another.  If Madi is going to an amusement park and then ends up having no night FD, then I think HS is F1.

Remember, RS keeps saying that if he said who is F1, then why did Peter's mom say 'Don't let her go' and why did Chris say, before you do this that upsets Peter.  That tells me he hears HS is F1 and has nothing to back it up.

Screencaps are great but the scenario has to make sense so I think we can look at which scenarios make sense with the evidence we currently have to get a better idea of the actual ending. We may not know for sure yet but we can potentially get closer to the truth.

Don’t we have the cap in Madi’s hotel room of them in bed in the morning? If that cap has been IDed as Madi’s hotel room then it has to be Madi’s feet we see.

Someone, I think @Bobette , sleuthed the most expensive FS was for Madi. IMHO that's a huge clue to Madi being Peter's F1.

We see a silhouette. We see fuzzy socks. I am just saying we don't have verification of where HS had her fantasy suite at.

atem wrote:We see a silhouette. We see fuzzy socks.  I am just saying we don't have verification of where HS had her fantasy suite at.  

Has that hotel room been IDed as the one Madi stayed in for FD? That is what I was asking about. If so, then it should be Madi in that cap.

GuardianAngel wrote:Someone, I think @Bobette , sleuthed the most expensive FS was for Madi. IMHO that's a huge clue to Madi being Peter's F1.

I do think Madi is Peter’s intended F1, but if she left the ending could be in play.

gabriele wrote:

atem wrote:We see a silhouette. We see fuzzy socks.  I am just saying we don't have verification of where HS had her fantasy suite at.  

Has that hotel room been IDed as the one Madi stayed in for FD? That is what I was asking about. If so, then it should be Madi in that cap.

Yes Bobbette figured it’s out. I think it was the Gold Coast casino suite. We see them in bed in the AM with colored fuzzy socks.

Tiggerlgh wrote:

gabriele wrote:

atem wrote:We see a silhouette. We see fuzzy socks.  I am just saying we don't have verification of where HS had her fantasy suite at.  

Has that hotel room been IDed as the one Madi stayed in for FD? That is what I was asking about. If so, then it should be Madi in that cap.

Yes Bobbette figured it’s out.  I think it was the Gold Coast casino suite.  We see them in bed in the AM with colored fuzzy socks.

Thanks! I just found that cap and the bed has those silver things (reading lights?) on the headboard. So, unless HA is at that hotel and has an identical bed for FS it is Madi.

The Hannah Ann stans on reddit are absolutely sure that silhouette photo in the FS is Hannah Ann.  They also think the girl in the red top on the boat in Peru is Hannah Ann.

Pretty much, every steamy makeout scene is Hannah Ann to them