Josh Murray - BIP - Famously Single - Season 3 - *Sleuthing - Spoilers*

jen689 wrote:

Jolena wrote:I met Josh in person and he was a total gentlemen and very nice....

Was he sober?

Yes he was sober and actually it was in a nightclub, my friend & I spent hours talking with him and he was kind, respectful ,attentive.

grace8136 wrote:


Wait... so is it true? Does Molly have Andi's old ring?!

No. Jason had bought Molly one and it looked like the one that Josh had given Andi.

Sprite wrote:

grace8136 wrote:


Wait... so is it true? Does Molly have Andi's old ring?!

No. Jason had bought Molly one and it looked like the one that Josh had given Andi.

If I remember correctly. Molly never got a Neil's ring because she was a second choice. On their anniversary or something like that, Jason and Neil surprised Molly by getting her a Neil Lane ring. Molly posted it on Instagram and Josh had a something to say about it how it looked like Andi 's ring.

I highly doubt Jason bought Molly a $50,000+ ring. Neil most likely just gave it to them, since it was still getting coverage in a magazine/Instagram. She received the ring for their 5 year wedding anniversary,since she was the only lady from the franchise that was married that didn't have a Neil ring (because Jason never proposed on the show, because of the switch obviously.)

IMO.

StacyNor wrote:

Sprite wrote:

grace8136 wrote:


Wait... so is it true? Does Molly have Andi's old ring?!

No. Jason had bought Molly one and it looked like the one that Josh had given Andi.

If I remember correctly. Molly never got a Neil's ring because she was a second choice. On their anniversary or something like that, Jason and Neil surprised Molly by getting her a Neil Lane ring. Molly posted it on Instagram and Josh had a something to say about it how it looked like Andi 's ring.

Is that rude to say the rings looked similar? That means the guys have similar taste in picking out rings. Josh obviously liked the ring when he picked it out. It might have just been a comment or a compliment.

Didn't Andi give Josh specific instructions on what ring to pick? Doubt it had anything to do with Josh's taste.

mindless wrote:Didn't Andi give Josh specific instructions on what ring to pick? Doubt it had anything to do with Josh's taste.

She did.

Here's the thing with Josh. Josh likes Josh, he likes people who like Josh and agree with everything he says. He's shy with women because he fears rejection so he'd rather not put himself in that position. That's how I've always seen him. 

However, that doesn't make him a bad guy, it makes him a guy with room for growth, like most. On the flip side, he's shown his capability of loving and loyalty. I think he'd do anything for someone he truly loves. In this respect I think he and Amanda have serious potential. I think she wants stability and loyalty and someone who will take care of her. That's all the things Josh loves to do. 

And I know we all can't stand Andi's book. But I actually hope Josh learns from it. Because I'm sure there's some shred of truth in there. You can't stalk your woman's social media. It's ok if she goes out with her girlfriends or takes a trip to Mexico with them. But in his defense he never trusted Andi, because she straight up lied to him. He needs to to find a balance of trust and I think that's something he can find with Amanda and have a good shot at a healthy happy relationship.

Eviebloom wrote:

StacyNor wrote:

Sprite wrote:


No. Jason had bought Molly one and it looked like the one that Josh had given Andi.

If I remember correctly. Molly never got a Neil's ring because she was a second choice. On their anniversary or something like that, Jason and Neil surprised Molly by getting her a Neil Lane ring. Molly posted it on Instagram and Josh had a something to say about it how it looked like Andi 's ring.

Is that rude to say the rings looked similar?  That means the guys have similar taste in picking out rings.  Josh obviously liked the ring when he picked it out.  It might have just been a comment or a compliment.  

It wasn't a compliment, as Molly appeared to be offended and angry afterward.
IMO.

I think Josh is just a dummy and didn't realize it's rude to compare the rings.

@SeekAny, ITA with your post!! Great thoughts! I doubt he'll learn because he seems incapable of admitting any faults but we'll see. Good luck to Amanda no matter what.

Let's not sell him short Alanna, he loves to admit he's "picky." That's like the classic non weakness weakness answer on a job interview! 

And dude, you're not picky, you get engaged on every TV show possible.

SeekAny wrote:Let's not sell him short Alanna, he loves to admit he's "picky." That's like the classic non weakness weakness answer on a job interview! 

And dude, you're not picky, you get engaged on every TV show possible.

Good posts! I'm excited to stalk witness their relationship dynamic.