Andi Dorfman & Josh Murray - Fan Forum - General Discussion Thread #3

[Admin]

This is a continuation of Andi and Josh's original Fan Forum. Due to the news of their break up, we will continue to have this thread open in order for Fans to be able to discuss the situation as Fans. It will remain open as long as there is activity or we feel it should be closed.

There is a new Josh Fan Forum and a new Andi Fan Forum. There is also a Josh and Andi General Discussion thread. Please be aware of where you are posting and respect the rules of the title of the thread.

All Fan forum's are in the Category titled Fan Forum.

All General Discussion threads are in the Category of General Discussion.

Please do not speculate anything related to the family. Any family discussions will be deleted, and may warrant a warning.

Josh Andi General discussion

Josh Fan Forum

Andi Fan Forum







TY.

[stuckinsc]

One of my all time favorite break up songs. Hope it might help some process through.

[edenpol]

One of my all time favorite break up songs.  Hope it might help some process through.

Boys || Men Episode 3

[jlccaz]

A little amusement for the fans ... what makes satire brilliant and entertaining is taking something literally true and exaggerating it slightly to show the humor... with the aim of communicating some perspective.

For every busted-up couple (and this one ended on the sooner rather than later side of spectrum actually), there follows happiness, new couples, babies, better matches, etc.  It's all part of the journey of life.

[AnandaMarie]

I read what you guys posted on the last thread. I don't see how magazines could say that Josh called it off or Andi called it off. Their statement just said that it was a mutual decision. It probably wasn't, but magazines cant just assume which one of them ended it. I personally think that it might have been Josh but I could be wrong and I don't think magazines should publish anything like that because neither Andi or Josh indicated any such thing.
I just hope they work things out. Their love was so special.

[stuckinsc]

A little amusement for the fans ... what makes satire brilliant and entertaining is taking something literally true and exaggerating it slightly to show the humor... with the aim of communicating some perspective.

For every busted-up couple (and this one ended on the sooner rather than later side of spectrum actually), there follows happiness, new couples, babies, better matches, etc.  It's all part of the journey of life.

OMG, jlccaz, you might secretly have needed to be a Nick fan as he loves WF too.  The whole dog Murray thing was from Anchorman.  But this scene is hilarious.

I can honestly say, I don't think Andi is a trampire and I don't think either in this relationship cheated.

BTW, Eden, I am sorry, I was not trying to make you sad. I just love the song and had blocked out the horrible singing of epi 3 all together.

[sara11]

A little amusement for the fans ... what makes satire brilliant and entertaining is taking something literally true and exaggerating it slightly to show the humor... with the aim of communicating some perspective.

For every busted-up couple (and this one ended on the sooner rather than later side of spectrum actually), there follows happiness, new couples, babies, better matches, etc.  It's all part of the journey of life.

Haha thanks for this, so funny and literally what jodi fans are going through right now. 

[soccermom333]

One of my all time favorite break up songs.  Hope it might help some process through.

Boys || Men Episode 3

Don't cry eden!! I think she was just trying to lighten the load. Take your time and grieve the way you want.

[aviej]

Guys sorry to rehash things but... I brought myself to rewatch the Access Hollwood interview versus CH. They were TOTALLY different! You can tell that in the AH interview Josh was still hopefull in a wedding in 2015. But when it came to CH's interview, things took a turn for the worse. I think they did have issues prior to the premiere but something just happened in between those two interviews. It would be interesting to find out which interview they did first though.

[sara11]

Guys sorry to rehash things but... I brought myself to rewatch the Access Hollwood interview versus CH. They were TOTALLY different! You can tell that in the AH interview Josh was still hopefull in a wedding in 2015. But when it came to CH's interview, things took a turn for the worse. I think they did have issues prior to the premiere but something just happened in between those two interviews. It would be interesting to find out which interview they did first though.

In both interviews they got awkward around the wedding topic: in the AH one, Josh changed the topic from pinterest boards about weddings to Andi's cooking and in the CH one the moment he mentioned wedding they dropped their arms around one another and stood awkwardly for a while.

[sara11]

They shocked fans with news of their breakup on Thursday, but a source close to Andi Dorfmanand Josh Murray tells PEOPLE that the separation is indeed amicable. 

"There was no cheating, no event or incident that led to the breakup," says the source. "Andi and Josh spent their engagement working on their relationship and it just didn't work out. They figured out that they're not supposed to be together."


http://www.people.com/article/bachelorette-andi-dorfman-josh-murray-split-breakup

[aviej]

Can we believe this information coming from People? I guess so. If what the article says is true that it alludes to the fact that Josh and Andi are two different people with different priorities.

[Sponsored content]