Josh Murray - Bachelorette 10 - Discussion - #10

BohemianNika wrote:

Kashathediva wrote:No accounting for the other 50%. Maybe drunk or middle school girls.

Quick question - if I were to make a comment (here or in Andi's discussion thread) about the people who give the book 1 star, that would be also within the rules?

It's within the rules as long as the post is referring to "people" outside of this forum.

As always, there are fan threads for those who do not care to read negative opinions, because this forum discusses topics whether they are positive or negative. All members are welcomed to post their thoughts.

GA, thank you for your answer.

The thing is, although technically I would be referring to people outside this forum, I would know that there are people here who wrote those 1 star reviews. To me, in a way, it would feel like talking about them as well. And that is a line I'm not willing to cross. All IMO of course.

Of course Josh is subtweeting. So not shocked. He's going to spill so much dirt on "Famously Single."

BohemianNika wrote:

Kashathediva wrote:No accounting for the other 50%. Maybe drunk or middle school girls.

Quick question - if I were to make a comment (here or in Andi's discussion thread) about the people who give the book 1 star, that would be also within the rules?

I don't see why it would not be within the rules. To make things clear: Amazon reviewers are Amazon reviewers. That has nothing more to do with this site than People mag posters, US mag posters etc.  BBF is not, nor has ever been a part of Amazon. Does this help? IF not please pm one of the mods and we will be glad to help you.

Edited to add: Goodreads is also another book reviewer. The reviews are not much different. IMO

Mustang19 wrote:I'm all for him helping himself, I just don't want to see him get sucked into the nastiness with her by opening a can of worms.

I tweeted him back on one of his tweets saying "keep it up you are the classy one Amen" he liked my post and tweeted back good message. I really think they will all ignore her.

That's not ignoring her though by posting bible quotes like that. He should have just left it at the comments he gave to US Weekly by wishing her peace. The media will eventually catch on and give Andi's book more attention something she wants. JMO.

I thought before the show, he tweeted bible quotes . I don't see why he should stop now just because he comes across as subtweeting and I agree with many on this that he has really handled this whole thing with so much class. Any action he takes about this whole situation will be understandable in my book, JMO.

Josh shouldn't bother responding in any way to the book/Andi because if he does then he's just giving Andi what she wants -- attention.

Jmo

Linds911 wrote:That's not ignoring her though by posting bible quotes like that. He should have just left it at the comments he gave to US Weekly by wishing her peace. The media will eventually catch on and give Andi's book more attention something she wants. JMO.

I often post reflective posts that have little to do with my day to day feelings or events and post them because I like them and believe in them. It could be as simple and uncomplicated as that.

Joel Osteen's #TameYourTongue sermon is a great one and it's perfect for Josh to hear right now.  I don't see it as subtweeting, I see it as his inspiration on a better way to handle things going on right now.

The fact that Andi acts just the opposite of the message is on her, not Josh.

lexforlife wrote:I thought before the show, he tweeted bible quotes . I don't see why he should stop now just because he comes across as subtweeting and I agree with many on this that he has really handled this whole thing with so much class. Any action he takes about this whole situation will be understandable in my book, JMO.

Totally agree he did it before they were ever together why should he stop now. Josh is handling this situation with pure class. JMO

A fictional novel  

In a statement to ABC News, Murray said, "How is one supposed to comment on a fictional novel? I choose to go through life building others up, not tearing them down. I wish her nothing but the best in her new career."

Source

His statements have been nice and polite and he's taken the high road, but he really needs to keep his mouth shut, IMO.  I have a feeling once FS airs, it's going to quickly undo all the high road and positive footing he's gained by mostly keeping quiet with only a few possible subtweets and statements made.  JMO.